A Saturday at a Columbus market hall, one stop for a day-trip client.
Referring a Dayton client to Columbus? Resideline's six-month medians were $132,000 in Dayton and $258,500 in Columbus, about 71 miles apart. Both showed a median of 15 days from listing to contract.
Picture the call. A Dayton agent I have never met is on the line, and a client of hers has just taken a job in Columbus. She has known this family through a purchase, a few years of ordinary life and now a big change. She does not want to hand them to a stranger from an online list. She wants to know that the person on the other end understands what her client is used to.
If you are that agent, this post is for you. I am Chrisi Hagan, a REALTOR with Collins Lassiter Group at Red 1 Realty, licensed in Ohio and working across Columbus and Central Ohio. Here is what I would want to know in your seat, with the source and date for every number so you can check my work.
How Do Dayton and Columbus Compare on the Numbers?
Here are the like-for-like figures. Resideline reported a six-month median sold price of $132,000 in Dayton across 1,054 closings, with a median of $97 per square foot. For Columbus, Resideline reported $258,500 across 4,563 closings and $187 per square foot. Both pages were recently updated.
Resideline also tracks sales that never appeared on a listing service. In Dayton, 19 percent of closings never did, and the median of MLS-listed sales alone was $145,000. In Columbus, the MLS-only median was $265,650. I mention it so you can compare the numbers you quote your client with the numbers they see online.
For regional context, Columbus REALTORS reported a Central Ohio median of $350,000 in its latest report, and The Columbus Team reported $345,500. Those cover different months and a wider area than city limits, so I treat them as context, not a direct comparison.
What Does That Gap Mean for a Client's Budget?
It means the same budget usually buys fewer square feet in Columbus. As an illustration only, a 1,500-square-foot home at each city's median price per square foot works out to roughly $145,500 in Dayton and $280,500 in Columbus. That is arithmetic, not an appraisal, and condition, lot and location move the number.
The Columbus suburbs run higher. Resideline's six-month medians were $450,000 in Westerville and $440,000 in Hilliard, and $630,000 in Dublin. Those suburb figures are Resideline's, some from an earlier update, so compare like with like when you set expectations. I would rather walk through recent closed sales near the blocks a client likes than quote a town-wide number.
How Fast Do Homes Move in Both Markets?
Pace is closer than you might expect. Resideline shows a median of 15 days from listing to under contract in both Dayton and Columbus. Contract to closing is a median of 31 days in Dayton and 23 in Columbus.
In the suburbs, Resideline shows 10 days to contract in Westerville and Dublin and 5 in Hilliard, with 23, 25 and 32 days to closing. These are medians from subsets of closings, so they show direction and not promises.
How Far Is It, and Can a Client Tour in a Day?
Dayton and Columbus are about 71 miles apart by road, roughly an hour and eleven minutes at 60 miles per hour, according to MapsOf.net. That makes a Saturday look-around realistic, and a client can be home for dinner. One approach is a first visit with a short list of neighborhoods and a second visit once the list is narrower.
What Will Your Client Recognize in Central Ohio?
I translate lifestyle, not people. Dayton has a lot to love: the National Museum of the U.S. Air Force, with free admission, Carillon Historical Park, and Five Rivers MetroParks, which Destination Dayton lists as 18 parks across 16,000 acres, plus more than 340 miles of paved trails in the Miami Valley.
If your client loves their weekday trail time, I would start with Clintonville near the Olentangy Trail, or Dublin, where the visitors bureau lists more than 150 miles of bike trails. For a market hall on a Saturday, North Market downtown and its second location at Dublin's Bridge Park come to mind. Those are starting points, not promises of a match.
How Do I Work With Referring Agents?
I keep you in the loop at every milestone, from the first call through closing. Referral compensation, when applicable, is paid broker-to-broker under a written referral agreement. I am not going to put terms in a blog post, because those belong in a conversation between brokers.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I refer a client to a Columbus-area agent?
Send me your client's wish list, budget range and timeline, and we will set up a conversation. Referral compensation, when applicable, is paid broker-to-broker under a written referral agreement in accordance with Ohio license law. I keep you in the loop at every milestone, from the first call through closing.
Can my client buy in Columbus before visiting?
Many clients start with video tours and neighborhood research, and I would encourage at least one in-person visit, since lifestyle fit is hard to judge on a screen. Dayton is about 71 miles away, roughly an hour and eleven minutes by car, so a day trip is realistic. Inspections protect buyers either way.
How do home prices compare between Dayton and Columbus?
Resideline's six-month median sold price was $132,000 in Dayton and $258,500 in Columbus, with $97 and $187 per square foot. Suburbs run higher: Westerville was $450,000 and Hilliard $440,000. City figures blend many neighborhoods, so ask for recent sales near the areas your client prefers.
How long does a closing take in Columbus compared with Dayton?
Resideline shows a median of 23 days from contract to closing in Columbus and 31 in Dayton, and 15 days from listing to contract in both. Suburbs vary, from 23 days in Westerville to 32 in Hilliard. A client selling in Dayton while buying here should talk with a lender and title company early.
If you have a client headed to Columbus, I would be glad to have a conversation, share recent closed sales for the areas they are considering and talk through the calendar. Reach out any time, no pressure.
This content is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. All real estate services are provided in compliance with Fair Housing laws, RESPA, TCPA, the REALTOR® Code of Ethics, and Ohio Real Estate Commission advertising regulations. Equal Housing Opportunity. Chrisi Hagan, Collins Lassiter Group, Red 1 Realty.
Referral compensation, when applicable, is paid broker-to-broker under a written referral agreement in accordance with Ohio license law.